Welcome

Please join Advocates for Academic Freedom (AAF). Membership is free because you and your time are our most valuable assets. Our goals are to assure the academic freedom of all American students, to advocate the development of critical thinking skills in all educational settings, and to facilitate academic environments which respect robust thinking and discussion in all classrooms. To achieve these goals, we will advocate for libraries of federally and state funded schools to provide materials representing a balance of various points of view regarding science, history, social studies, health, and civics classes. Our blog is filled with information, we encourage your feedback and participation.

Click on the title of any of the blogs listed below, you will be brought to a page where you can post your comments. We will review and release the comments to the blog within a day or so.

Friday, March 9, 2012

EASY STEPS TO USE WHEN DONATING CURRENT-EVENTS MATERIALS

The Advocates for Academic Freedom home page provides a step-by-step process for donating materials to school libraries under the PHASE I button. PHASE II and PHASE III buttons include a sample step-by-step process for addressing the school board.

Advocates for Academic Freedom membership is free because we hope that you will organize parents in your neighborhood and donate two conservative magazines and one conservative newspaper to your local school library. That will cost about $200. After donating the materials, citizens should have a conversation with school administrators and school board members about using district funds to provide those materials in future years.

The fastest, easiest, and least expensive way to return traditional American values to educational settings is to insist that conservative political ideologies become part of the current-events studies that schools typically provide weekly.

Every person and situation will be different. The processes suggested under the PHASE buttons may be modified to address your specific situation.

After donating materials to the school library, please visit that library to make sure the donated items are displayed, to notify social studies and history teachers that the resources are available for their use, and to encourage your children to request access to those materials.

Wednesday, February 29, 2012

ONE EASY STEP TO IMPROVING THE SUCCESS RATE OF ANTI-BULLYING CURRICULA

State governments have wasted millions of dollars creating and implementing anti-bullying curriculums which have been destined for failure because of the institutionally accepted bullying practiced by most political and social institutions, including the educational system. If there is any chance of limiting bullying within the educational system, legislation must include anti-bullying standards for the role models and leadership of the very institutions required to implement the anti-bullying curriculums.

Educators recognize that school libraries set the intellectual and social tone of the school. Librarians have been diligent about including literature that recognizes the contributions made to America by every race and nationality. Books which provide positive representations of women and of every religion, culture, and life-style-choice are included in the library. Displays of magazines and current events materials include items that address all cultural and ethnic interests, hobbies, and most of the political spectrum. The current-events materials may include everything from Mother Jones, Monthly Review, Mother Earth News, to Time, and Newsweek; but one typically will not see a copy of a conservative magazine such as The Weekly Standard or National Review. Censorship is one of the most aggressive forms of bullying.

A Wisconsin teacher brought his fourth graders to the state capitol for a field trip and encouraged those children to participate in the anti-Governor Walker protests that are a well-known daily occurrence. When this instructor used his influence to encourage students to ignore the political views of their parents and to protest a Governor whom their parents support, intimidation was being used to bully young children. Fortunately, most teachers use better judgment.

When a student responds to discussion questions presented in health class by stating that he or she intends to practice abstinence and is met with derision, that is bullying. When the instructor does not stop the mocking and/or if he participates, the instructor not only condones these behaviors but he also becomes a bully. Peer pressure is often used to push children into abandoning their goals and values. A common peer-pressure tactic is represented by the false statement that “everybody does it”. Peer pressure is a form of bullying.

When students are required to view Al Gore’s mistake-ridden movie Inconvenient Truth every year of their school career but they are not required to view Cool It, a highly respected alternative scientific stand, not only have the political views of the student been minimized, but the school system has also bullied those students while ignoring its responsibility to teach critical thinking skills and research techniques. How can children analyze the significance of facts when only one side of an issue is presented in schools? Limiting resource materials is a form of bullying.

Many teachers are required to show the video The Story of Stuff which makes five false statements about the American government and capitalism during the first three minutes of the movie. When movies or school textbooks no longer provide the truth that America is a republic and falsely state that America is a Democracy, and when name calling and intimidation are used to prevent the truth from being revealed, that is bullying. When school systems are encouraged to intimidate systematically and bully our children into accepting falsehoods as truth, legislators and parents must take a stand.

If bullying in schools is going to subside, anti-bullying legislation must include well-defined examples of bullying, well-defined consequences for any acts of bullying, and standards which must be applicable to adults as well as to students in the educational setting. Once that has been accomplished, legislators must take a careful look at curriculum core standards for every subject area and assure that those standards are fact-based and scientifically sound, that the data is replicable, and that the content encourages respect for the traditions and customs that have served the American people so well for over 200 years. After all, those traditions include the right to practice any religion or life-style and must include those who value a republic, who choose abstinence, and who wish to evaluate all sides of any given issue.

Sunday, January 1, 2012

SUGGESTED SOCIAL STUDIES, HISTORY, AND POLITICAL SCIENCE CURRICULUMS FOR K-12

GRADE-LEVEL-APPROPRIATE CURRICULUM FOR THE STUDY OF SOCIAL STUDIES, HISTORY, GOVERNMENT, AND POLITICAL SCIENCE MUST INCLUDE TEXTBOOKS WHICH FOCUS UPON:
• The founding fathers, the Constitution, Bill of Rights, Federalist Papers, Northwest Ordinance of 1787, Declaration of Independence, Constitutional Convention, Ruler’s Law v People’s Law v no law and the 28 basic principles identified in the Federalist papers that are appropriate for each grade level
• Presentation of America as a Constitutional Republic and a detailed analysis of the differences between a republic and other forms of government
• Studies of the struggles and sacrifices made in the development of the American republic
• Writings of persons who participated in the establishment of our government and its major institutions
• Texts of at least one dozen Federalist Papers and/or documents created by the founders in which our founding fathers warned citizens about the danger of devolving into any form of democracy
• Writings by the founders, the philosophers, and the economists whose ideas influenced the development of the United States government and its documents including Cicero, Sir William Blackstone, and Alex de Tocqueville.
• Historical analysis of slavery as it has existed around the world, which countries eliminated the practice from their social structure and why, and which countries continue to practice slavery and why
• Recognition of the influence that America’s First Ladies had upon the social and political issues of their day
• Recognition of the basic principles found in the Bible, Koran, Torah, and the Sutras by the masters of Buddhism and the historical role each religion played in the social and political aspects of American society
• History of Black-American founding fathers, political leaders, entrepreneurs, inventors, scientists, etc. from the 1600s to the present
• History of influential minority women in American History. Some examples: Pocahontas who is the Powhatan princess who saved the life of Captain John Smith; Sojourner Truth who is a lecturer, an escaped slave, and abolitionist; and Bell Hooks a black author, educator and activist
• Writings of Alex de Tocqueville, a French jurist and historian in the 1800s whose historical analysis of America’s educational and political system should be compared with the approach used by current American historians
• Analysis of Amendments to the Constitution and the impact they have had on the American economic, political, and social systems
• Opportunities to analyze the advantages and disadvantages of a republic, a democracy, socialism, communism, fascism, Marxism, or any other form of government
• Analysis of the history of taxation in America and its relationship to fiscal accountability and fiscal responsibility
• Analysis of the economic standards of Adam Smith, F.A. Hayek, Milton Friedman, and John M. Keynes while analyzing the impact each economic philosophy has had on the American economic system and on the global economic system
• Analysis of the contributions made by American women such as: Elizabeth Blackwell who was the first woman to receive a medical degree; Mary Katherine Goddard who was the first woman publisher , first woman postmaster, publisher of the Providence Gazette, and the individual who provided the first copies of the Declaration of Independence; Marian Wright Edelman who was a lawyer, educator and founder of the Children’s Defense Fund; and Regina Anderson, a black librarian and playwright
• Historical factors involved in the formation of the Ku Klux Klan in America
• History of the 13, 14,and 15th Amendments to the Constitution
• History of the development of the 1965 Civil Rights Act
• Dred Scott Decision and its history
• The Jim Crow Laws and their history

Sunday, August 14, 2011

CHEATING BY ATLANTA EDUCATORS REVEALS SPECIFIC CHANGES NEEDED

The current revelation that a significant number of Atlanta teachers and administrators were caught changing student test scores reveals the desperation educators experience when they are held accountable for productivity while given little power to make classroom decisions that would promote maximum academic achievement among students.

Educational experts continue to prepare new teachers to use the same teaching methods which have failed our children for seventy years. Administrators endorse these inadequate methods by basing teacher evaluations on the teachers’ implementation of the same methods of instruction. Cooperative grouping of children and the inquiry and discovery methods of instruction all have positive aspects, but they are not necessarily the most effective methods for introducing new concepts to children or for development of student understanding of fundamental principles.

The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics recommended that calculators replace the memorization of basic facts, that students be required to do less pencil and paper assignments, and that math homework be limited. These approaches have failed our students, and the proof is in the rapid decline of student test scores over the last seventy years.

If teachers are going to be held accountable for academic success of students, teachers must be empowered to select the teaching methods which will bring positive results to any specific learning situation. That includes a return to a reasonable amount of homework in core subjects where repetition is essential to memorize basic facts as in math and grammar and where extensive reading is necessary as in literature and history.

Academic success has also been hindered by heterogeneous grouping of children, a result of the Brown vs. the Board of Education law suit in the 1950s. Consequently, each classroom must include students of differing ability levels and diverse backgrounds creating insurmountable problems in many classrooms. This level of diversity in the classroom requires the teacher to find a teaching method which reaches all students equally. This is often impossible.

Continuing to ignore this truth almost guarantees poor academic results. Students who struggle academically need to have new information presented differently than a presentation would be for students who have a strong background, interest, or aptitude for the subject. Yet, teachers are not given the flexibility to group children according to learning style or needs, but they are held solely responsible for the consequences of this impractical situation.

While these problems are not the only ones which limit a teacher’s opportunity to help students excel, they are among the most damaging. This professional educational environment is not unlike holding a teacher accountable for maintaining high academic and behavioral standards even though her mouth has been taped shut and her hands tied behind her back. Such an untenable educational environment is destructive to the educational process, to students, and to our society.

Curriculum materials too often focus on political and social goals rather than mastery of basic skills that are prerequisites for student proficiency in the subject. Even math teachers have been required to spend class time showing videos like THE STORY OF STUFF and AN INCONVENIENT TRUTH which do not address age-appropriate math issues relevant to the class curriculum.

Critical thinking skills have been removed from classroom curriculum because their development would require two sides of an issue to be discussed. There has been no time planned for this discussion in the modern classroom so one side of an issue has been imposed time and again upon both students and teachers even though the irrelevance of the socio/political goal to the subject matter is clear. This would not happen if student academic achievement were the primary goal.

An investigator of the Alabama cheating stated, “In sum, a culture of fear, intimidation and retaliation permeated the APS system from the highest ranks down. Cheating was allowed to proliferate until, in the words of one former APS principal, ‘it became intertwined in Atlanta Public Schools ... a part of what the culture is all about.’ ” Many educators are trying to use this experience as proof that assessment tools are the culprit, but that is the wrong approach to take.

Children must learn how to take tests because they face tests throughout their lives. ACT and SAT tests are required to enter college, and college exams provide the main criteria for determining a student’s grade. Teachers, doctors, dentists, lawyers, realtors, electricians, and plumbers are all tested to prove their competence and their understanding of the subject matter. Testing is NOT the problem. A culture that refuses to place the academic achievement of students above political and social ideologies is the problem.

The most effective solution to the problem of cheating among teachers and administrators is to empower teachers to use the teaching methods which best meet the needs of their students, to refuse curriculum that does not focus on the subject, to provide curriculums that encourage the mastery of basic skills, and to require students to meet practical academic expectations by consistently showing their work and finishing reasonable amounts of homework. This support for teachers must come from the American public.

Friday, August 12, 2011

PLEASE TEACH TO THE TEST

Ben Franklin said that America will be a republic “as long as you can keep it” and Abe Lincoln said that the philosophy of the classroom of one generation becomes the philosophy of the government of the next generation. Please join Advocates for Academic Freedom and become part of a grassroots movement to return traditional American values, fact-based curriculum, and accountability to education. We need your voice and involvement if we are going to keep our republic. To join, click on the hot link: http://advocatesforacademicfreedom.org/

PLEASE TEACH TO THE TEST

Many educational leaders are using the cheating tragedy discovered among Atlanta teachers and administrators as an opportunity to attack the value of testing for accountability. Educators encourage eliminating current skill-based objective testing requirements so that teachers can teach instead of “teaching to the test”. This is a specious argument manipulated by educational experts through ever-changing professional jargon. Once the jargon is eliminated, the flaw in the argument is clear. Lost in the debate is the fact that testing can be a successful accountability tool if several basic changes occur in the educational system. The circuitous debate will continue until the underlying issue has been addressed: test results may be used to hold teachers accountable for that which is beyond their control.

Society has the right to set academic expectations for schools and to expect that accurate methods be used to verify student mastery of basic skills. For example: society has the right to expect students to have instant recall of multiplication facts one through ten and to expect an assessment of the student’s level of mastery. In this case, please, teach to the test!

“Teaching to the test” means to some that tests may include questions which are not a part of the mandatory curriculum and require teachers to teach lessons that will simply assure the student test successfully. The argument proves that teachers are given notice about the types of questions their students will be expected to answer on the test making this another illegitimate argument with two reasonable solutions.

First, teachers need to determine whether the skill is grade-level appropriate. If it is, the real question should be, “Why was the skill missing from the district-approved curriculum?” Typically, teachers write additional lessons to compensate for the flawed district curriculum and to provide the student an opportunity to learn this necessary skill. In this case, teaching to the test can provide greater opportunity for students.

Second, suppose the test question is not grade-level appropriate. For example: it is unreasonable to expect a typical third-grade student to answer questions about the Pythagorean Theorem. In this case, school leadership may request the company which designed the test to eliminate the question from future tests for that grade level and exclude the question in final test results. This is a natural process for developing effective testing tools. There is no need for any student or school district to endure long-term consequences for this type of error. In this situation, teaching to the test has increased communication between educators and creators of tests improving the quality of the testing instrument.

Educators must respect the fact that testing is an accepted accountability tool used by colleges, employers, the military and other entities seeking to define skill level. Children need to be adequately prepared for this level of evaluation.

When educators believe that developing successful testing skills prepares children for the real world, they will not only prepare children for life’s challenges but teachers will also have a valuable tool to help them recognize the specific academic needs of each student.

Test taking skills include a respect for important subtleties of language. Many test questions ask children to compare and contrast ideas, to identify advantages or disadvantages, to know the difference between a graph and a chart. Good test-taking skills encompass good life skills such as learning to pace one-self to avoid lingering too long over difficult questions and to plan to return to them later. Students are taught to identify key words for success such as finding “action” words and making sure that each action item is completed.

When “teaching to the test” has so many advantages for students, why do so many educators undermine the experience? It is not testing that worries teachers but the probability that they will be held accountable for test results when many factors that affect academic success are beyond their control or influence. The following are just a few of the changes which must occur before teachers can accept full accountability for test results.

1. Communication between school districts, the state, text book companies, and publishers of testing materials must be improved to promote creation of testing tools compatible with the state’s curriculum. State curriculums must be skill based rather than “innovative”.
2. Teachers must be treated as professionals and given the right to decide which teaching methods and strategies to use in their classroom. Administrators must support all reasonable choices made by the teacher.
3. School boards, school districts, and administrators must no longer require implementation of any teaching strategy which has not been proven academically sound. Studies must be scientifically based and the results replicable and available to teachers before implementation. No Child Left Behind (NCLB) legislation promotes this requirement.
4. States must meet their obligation to provide clearly stated, reasonable standards for each grade level. NCLB legislation establishes this requirement.
5. Schools must have dependable, adequate funding to provide updated curriculum that meets changing curriculum requirements. NCLB provides good funding in this area.
6. Adequate, dependable funding must be made available for testing supplies and for communication of testing results. Until NCLB provided significant funding, many states had no funding for regular testing tools, for the time and personnel needed to correct the products of assessment tools, or for distribution of the data provided.
7. Teachers must be allowed to participate in regular evaluations of their administrators’ support of district academic and behavioral standards and of their support for teachers attempting to meet those district standards.

Teachers have little or no control over problems identified by this partial list of changes which are needed before public educators can focus effectively on the academic success of their students. Until teachers have a reasonable measure of control over factors which limit academic success of their students, teachers will continue to resist being held primarily accountable for that success.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

THIS IS AN EXCELLENT RESOURCE THAT MAY HELP CHILDREN WHO ARE STRUGGLING WITH MATH OR SCIENCE PRINCIPLES

This website is worth the time to visit. There is help for students with questions about all levels of math and science study.Simply click on the title of this post and you will be taken to the Khan Academy.